Teams 
 | | METS ALL-STARS | | |
| | |||
| |
| ||
| Player | Position | Year(s) |
| ||
| Edgardo Alfonzo | 2B | 2000 |
| ||
| Richie Ashburn | OF | 1962 |
| ||
| Carlos Beltran | OF | 2005, '06, '07, '09 |
| ||
| Armando Benitez | RHP | 2003 |
| ||
| Yogi Berra | Manager | 1974 |
| ||
| Bobby Bonilla | IF/OF | 1993, '95 |
| ||
| Gary Carter | C | 1985, '86, '87, '88 |
| ||
| David Cone | RHP | 1988, '92 |
| ||
| Ron Darling | RHP | 1985 |
| ||
| Sid Fernandez | LHP | 1986, '87 |
| ||
| John Franco | LHP | 1990 |
| ||
| Tom Glavine | LHP | 2004, '06 |
| ||
| Dwight Gooden | RHP | 1984, '85, '86, '88 |
| ||
| Jerry Grote | C | 1968, '74 |
| ||
| Bud Harrelson | SS | 1970, '71 |
| ||
| Keith Hernandez | 1B | 1984, '86, '87 |
| ||
| Gil Hodges | Manager | 1970 |
| ||
| Todd Hundley | C | 1996, '97 |
| ||
| Ron Hunt | 2B | 1964, '66 |
| ||
| Davey Johnson | Manager | 1987 |
| ||
| Howard Johnson | 3B, OF | 1989, '91 |
| ||
| Lance Johnson | OF | 1996 |
| ||
| Bobby Jones | RHP | 1997 |
| ||
| Cleon Jones | OF | 1969 |
| ||
| Dave Kingman | OF | 1976 |
| ||
| Jerry Koosman | LHP | 1968, '69 |
| ||
| Ed Kranepool | 1B | 1965 |
| ||
| Al Leiter | LHP | 2000 |
| ||
| Paul Lo Duca | C | 2006 |
| ||
| Pedro Martinez | RHP | 2005, '06 |
| ||
| Jon Matlack | LHP | 1974, '75, '76 |
| ||
| Willie Mays | OF | 1972, '73 |
| ||
| Lee Mazzilli | OF | 1979 |
| ||
| Tug McGraw | LHP | 1972 |
| ||
| Mike Piazza | C | 1998, '99, 2000, '01, '02, '04, '05 |
| ||
| Jesse Orosco | LHP | 1983, '84 |
| ||
| Rick Reed | RHP | 1998, 2001 |
| ||
| Jose Reyes | SS | 2006, '07, '10 |
| ||
| Francisco Rodriguez | RHP | 2009 |
| ||
| Bret Saberhagen | RHP | 1994 |
| ||
| Johan Santana | LHP | 2009 |
| ||
| Tom Seaver | RHP | 1967, '68, '69, '70, '71, '72, '73, '75, '76 |
| ||
| Duke Snider | OF | 1963 |
| ||
| John Stearns | C | 1977, '79, '80, '82 |
| ||
| Darryl Strawberry | OF | 1984, '85, '86, '87, '88, '89, '90 |
| ||
| Frank Viola | LHP | 1990, '91 |
| ||
| Billy Wagner | LHP | 2007, '08 |
| ||
| David Wright | 3B | 2006, '07, '08, '09, '10 |
| ||
| Joel Youngblood | OF | 1981 |
| ||
| Pat Zachry | RHP | 1978 |
